“Rest in Peace”

rest in peace

After another mass school shooting yesterday in Florida that left 17 students and teachers dead, the masses of social commentary, as well as the County Sheriff in charge of the investigation, can only say “may they rest in peace”.

We have been wondering for a while now where these politically correct sayings come from.  Unfortunately, most of them come from religion which is the great backdrop against which people search for comfort and answers in death.  Unfortunately, a growing number of us have dispelled with religion, so these statements are meaningless to us, and in some cases downright offensive.

From our position of reason and secular thinking, “rest in peace”, “prayers sent”,  and most other non-personal epitaphs are empty of meaning and moronic at best. These statements are not heard or felt by the dead, and family and friendly survivors are hardly helped by these “sayings”.  We know it is difficult to know what to say to senseless death and destruction, especially of young people in their prime.  Yet, it sounds and feels so trivial to hear and see these expressions at every wake, funeral, or social media posting regarding those who have died.

So, what DO we say to survivors of the dead?  We suggest that words are cheap.  Hugs, cooking a meal, help with expenses of burying and remembering the dead…actions speak louder than words, especially in these scenarios of comforting the living.

The worst things to say are…”he/she is in a better place”,  “they are at rest now” (no, they are dead), “It was God’s will”, or “I know just how you feel”.  None of these statements are true or helpful, and disingenuous at best.  Those statements are just about you and your beliefs or inability to truly care or communicate.

So, next time we want to express “condolences” (which might be one of the best words to describe our sentiments), think before you speak or write.  Make your expressions more personal and do not assume that the victims or their loved ones appreciate trite expressions.  A simple hug, nod, shedding tears with them…THAT is the true expression of solidarity with those who have lost a loved one. God had nothing to do with willing these deaths, and instead, it is much more humane to deal directly with the cause and effect of these tragedies.

One Comment

Add yours →

  1. Oh boy, this may be your blog that I most agree with. Every time I see “thoughts and prayers” I just think how banal can a statement be ? Maybe the person posting or speaking to an interviewer feels a little better about themselves or feels somehow involved in the situation. I see it as an empty meaningless comment that does no good for anyone, except maybe the speaker. I haven’t posted anything on Facebook or anywhere else about this massacre
    ( not “tragedy” ) because there is absolutely nothing I can say that will mean anything to those involved. The first people that came into my mind were my kids in West Palm Beach, one county north of this happening. Now Mark and Crystal have to talk to their kids about how to keep from being murdered while they are at school. As soon as I heard about it I called Crystal just to tell her that I love all of them. Maybe I can actually DO something. Somehow we need to get the money out of politics. We have to get Citizens United repealed ( fat chance !) and the NRA money out of our government ( sorry Tom) Both parties are supported by the NRA. We need to find candidates that refuse NRA money. We need to support candidates who believe in sensible gun control. We need to stop thinking that we have done something useful by posting “thoughts and prayers” on Facebook.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: